| Year | Captain | Best & Fairest |
| 1965 | I.R. Parker | J.H. Hyland |
| 1966 | Bruce. Crossley | C.M. Keeshan |
| 1967 | Bruce. Crossley | Barry Lay |
| 1968 | Bruce Crossley | W.G. Andrews, D.G. Williamson |
| 1969 | D.G. Williamson | Graham Templar |
| 1970 | David Rutherford | Kel Rogash |
| 1971 | Ernie McArthur | Graham Templar |
| 1972 | Barry Brockley | Robert David |
| 1973 | L.eon Moran | Mark Radford |
| 1974 | Bruno Scarcella | Leon Moran |
| 1975 | Bruno Scarcella | Mark Radford |
| 1976 | Bruno Scarcella | Glenn Anderson |
| 1977 | Peter Brukner | Lawrie McGee |
| 1978 | Jack Hamilton | Gerry Westmore |
| 1979 | Gerry Westmore | Ross Patterson |
| 1980 | Geoff Ellison | Richard Russell |
| 1981 | Michael Bourke | Anthony Fowler |
| 1982 | Phil Hill | Chris. Miller |
| 1983 | Roger Collins | Gerry Westmore |
| 1984 | Gerry Westmore | Peter Cooke |
| 1985 | Matt Wilson | Angus Mitchell |
| 1986 | Shane Rothe | Mick Hickey |
| 1987 | Mick Hickey | Mick Hickey |
| 1988 | Richard Robinson | Mick Hickey |
| 1989 | Mick Hickey | Andrew Kennedy |
| 1990 | Mick Hickey | Mick Hickey |
| 1991 | Steve Dobson | |
| 1992 | John Dawson, Tim Jackson | |
| 1993 | Geoff Markley | |
| 1994 | Jimmy Norman | Jonathan Hutchins |
| 1995 | Jimmy Norman | Dom Bolton |
| 1996 | Jimmy Norman, Paul Stephens | John Garnaut |
| 1997 | Damien McAloon | Darrell Gust |
| 1998 | Damien McAloon | Gavin Evans |
| 1999 | Lee Tweedle | Hugh Nailon |
| 2000 | Michael Thomas | A. Brown |
| 2001 | Michael Thomas | Damien McAloon |
| 2002 | Michael Thomas | Michael Thomas |
| 2003 | Damien McAloon | Michael Thomas |
| 2004 | Tom Hutchins | R.S. Martin |
| 2005 | Tom Hutchins | Dirk Heinz |
| 2006 | Chris Baumgartner | |
| 2007 | Martin Kelly | |
| 2008 | Andrew Henderson | Evan Wilkinson |
| 2009 | Alex Suvoltos | Ben Millard/Isaac Orr |
| 2010 | Al Lyon | James Van de Pol |
| 2011 | Ben Millard, Al Lyon | Ben Millard |
| 2012 | Ben Millard | David Withers |
| 2013 | Ben Millard | Tom Girdwood |
| 2014 | Tom Girdwood | Tom Girdwood |
| 2015 | Tom Girdwood | Tom Girdwood |
| 2016 | Tom Girdwood | Dirk Heinz |
| 2017 | Tom Girdwood/Ed Ratcliffe | Tim Carr, Louis Wardle |
| 2018 | Tom Girdwood | Sean Carr |
| 2019 | Damien Barton, Jamie Mugavin | Kirk Mahon |
| 2020 | No Contest | No Contest |
| 2021 | Andy Batarilo; Jamie Mugavin | Scott Wylie |
| 2022 | David Morgan | James Curran |
